NFU Blog

Rebuilding trust in finance

As some of readers might have noticed, NFU has the topic of trust in finance as its top policy priority in 2016.

So why is trust in finance important? Finance, whether bank or insurance, is fundamentally a social activity. Finance is about aiding customers, be they individuals, firms, or institutions, to overcome financial insecurity and to build value for the future.

As a consequence, the goal of financial firms should be to maximize added value for their customers – and the profits should come as a result. Is this the goal of modern finance? In too many instances, the response is no.

Take the chairman of a big Nordic bank as an example. When asked what his responsibility as bank leader is, he replied: to deliver maximum returns to the shareholders. And why? Because legislation stipulates it. Neither himself nor the bank had any other responsibility aside from that one, he emphasized. Any other end goals are for politicians or citizens to voice and implement, using legislation to define and limit financial activities.

Following this line of thought, the way in which financial firms should act to rebuild trust is to make sure that they comply with rules and regulations. Since the financial crisis in 2008 a great mass of such rules and regulations has been produced, which in practice means that financial firms build trust by hiring compliance staff that make sure the firms abide by those same rules.

But is that the way to rebuild trust on the long term? Research indicates otherwise.

As David de Cremer, Professor of Management at Cambridge University, recently pointed out (https://hbr.org/2015/03/why-our-trust-in-banks-hasnt-been-restored) three essential factors are needed to be perceived as trustworthy: ability, integrity, and benevolence. de Cremer holds that benevolence is a disregarded factor in the discussion about trust in finance.

Benevolence essentially means having somebody else’s interest at heart. This does not rule out that you can have your own best interest at heart at the same time. But it implies a certain care for your neighbour’s well-being, who – and this is supported in research – reciprocates with trusting you only when she clearly feels that her interests are catered to.

So are the current business practices in finance benevolent, and conducive to trust? Customer outcomes in financial firms are to a great extent a result of the way employees interact with customers. So a central element would be to make sure employees are encouraged to act in the best interest of the customer, which is to be allowed to act with his or her best interest in mind. When a financial institution puts shareholder value maximisation as the overarching goal, the incentives given to employees logically are designed to support the same goal. If on top of that value maximisation is expected on a quarterly basis, the incentives tend to align – and more often than not at the expense of the client.

Rebuilding trust in finance therefore require management models that acknowledge the need for benevolence. Consequently, business models should strive to connect with customers on a personal level and finance employees should be allowed to put their clients’ best interest first. Hard economic facts should be complemented with softer, relationship-based credit assessments. And having shareholder value maximisation as the goal for a firm – in the words of former General Electric CEO Jack Welch “the dumbest idea in the world” – must be replaced with putting clients and their financial needs first.

Many talk about trust in the financial world, but few really do anything. From NFU’s side, our first contribution is a soon-to-be-published research report on the use of performance measurement systems in the Nordic financial sectors. Indicative results clearly show that you get what you measure, and the way finance employees’ performance is measured does matter for the relationship with the client – and whether a benevolent business practice is achieved. Thereby, finance employees matter for restoring trust in finance, and as such they are important stakeholders in the discussion about how to build it back up again on the long term.

Arvid Ahrin

General Secretary (Parental leave)
Email: aal@nordicfinancialunions.org
Phone: +46 708 522 443
Twitter: @ahrinNFU

Related posts

2019.12.16 | NFU Blog
16 december, 2019

Remember to look at the big picture

That is my key takeaway from my eleven years at NFU. When I started in November 2008, the big picture in the Nordic and European finance sectors was changing dramatically. The biggest financial crisis in a century unfolded before our eyes, destroying trillions of euros and dollars in assets and hundreds of thousands of finance jobs all over Europe. The big and the small, the faraway and the close, the perspectives blended rapidly together and NFU had to navigate through it all.
Read more
2019.12.15 | NFU Blog
15 december, 2019

Europe moves on Human Rights Due Diligence?

At NFU we are constantly monitoring the development in the sectors, both at Nordic, European and global level. 2019 has been characterized by an increasingly intense focus on sustainability, and particularly relating to the environment and climate change. In the wake of this green focus, another issue has (re)emerged at European level, namely the issue of Human Rights Due Diligence (HRDD).
Read more
2019.12.15 | NFU Blog
15 december, 2019

Managing the digital transformation in the Nordics

The transition into a digital age is challenging the future of work and the occupational structures in society. In the financial sector, we see this development through the introduction of AI, Robo-advisors, big data and Regtech, which requires extensive reskilling and upskilling of employees. It is, however, essential to take control of the narrative on the digital transformation so that employees are not left alone in this societal transformation.
Read more